🧪 QA Engineer
No acceptance criteria are defined in the spec. That needs to change before implementation starts — I can't write tests without knowing what "done" looks like. Here's what I'd…
🔧 Backend Engineer
The API surface is clean and the intent is clear. Before implementation, I want to nail down the semantics of three things: the suggestion algorithm, the PATCH idempotency,…
💻 Kai — Frontend Engineer
Good spec to work from. My main concern is state management complexity — the panel state machine and shared sheet component need deliberate design decisions before…
🎨 Atlas — UI/UX Designer
Overall this spec is solid and consistent with the existing system. A few things I want the team to think about before we implement.
Design system consistency
-…
⚙️ Backend Engineer — Discussion Summary
Interactive discussion working through all open backend design decisions. All items resolved.
Resolved items
- Ingredient matching — by…
🧪 QA Engineer — Senior QA Engineer (Round 2)
The spec update addresses the sync model cleanly — section 4 is now "Sync model" with explicit rules. This unblocks writing accurate test cases.…
🔒 Sable — Security Engineer (Round 2)
The spec update is a net positive for security. Removing WebSocket/SSE eliminates an entire authentication surface. The remaining attack surface is…
⚙️ Backend Engineer — Senior Backend Engineer (Round 2)
The spec update removes real-time broadcast from the data operations — CHECK OFF and ADD CUSTOM are now simple mutations without…
🖥️ Kai — Senior Frontend Engineer (Round 2)
Spec update looks good — section 4 now clearly says "server-authoritative, form actions, no WebSocket/SSE." This is exactly the model I'd…
🎨 Atlas — UI/UX Designer (Round 2)
The spec update (e12fb72) addresses my main concern — liveness is gone, "Shared with household" replaces "N members online" everywhere. The visual…
Spec committed: specs/frontend/j2-add-meal.html (commit 693ec2b)
🧪 QA Engineer — Senior QA Engineer
Questions & Observations
- Acceptance criteria gap — "no live list, simple refresh": The issue body still says "Each check/uncheck syncs in…
🔒 Sable — Security Engineer
Questions & Observations
- Real-time sync removed — good for security scope. No WebSocket/SSE means no new authentication surface for persistent…
⚙️ Backend Engineer — Senior Backend Engineer
Questions & Observations
- Shopping list generation logic: The spec says "Ingredients from all planned meals are collected" and "Shared…
🖥️ Kai — Senior Frontend Engineer
Questions & Observations
- No real-time sync simplifies things massively. The issue body says "Each check/uncheck syncs in real-time to all…
🎨 Atlas — UI/UX Designer
Questions & Observations
- The issue says "Each check/uncheck syncs in real-time to all connected household members." However, the decision is **no live list —…