🔒 Sable — Security Engineer
This is the foundational defense layer. Without it, issues #2 (invite brute force) and the credential stuffing vector are wide open. Let me add the threat model…
🔐 Sable — Security Engineer
C3 is read-only and planner-only, which makes the attack surface smaller than D1 or J4. But there are a few things worth flagging given the score algorithm and…
🧪 QA Engineer
Small security config change with targeted test needs. Here's the coverage I'd want:
Integration tests — profile-gating approach:
@ActiveProfiles("prod"): GET…
🧪 QA Engineer
Rate limiting is deceptively tricky to test correctly. Here's the full test plan.
Unit tests:
- Rate limiter allows N requests within the window → all succeed
- Rate…
🎨 Atlas — UI/UX Designer
B2 is a well-structured spec but there are a few gaps in the visual system that need resolution before Kai implements the hero variants and the content layout.
**Her…
🏗️ Backend Engineer — Spring Boot / PostgreSQL Specialist
Agreed this is critical. Let me lay out the implementation options with the tradeoffs clearly, since the issue mentions a few…
🔧 Backend Engineer — Spring Boot / PostgreSQL Specialist
Good catch — permitAll() on Swagger in production is a common oversight. The two proposed fixes have different tradeoffs, and I'd…
🧪 QA Engineer — Test Coverage Plan for C3
C3 is a read-only display screen, which makes the frontend testing lighter — but the backend algorithm powering the scores needs rigorous coverage…
🔒 Sable — Security Engineer
B2 is a read-only screen but there are meaningful security considerations around resource access, image handling, and what data the API response exposes.
**Broken…
🎨 Atlas — UI/UX Designer
This is a backend authorization issue, but the design layer has a role to play in preventing confusion and misuse at the UI level.
Role-aware UI:
- The invite…
👨💻 Kai — Frontend Engineer
Rate limiting is a backend concern, but it surfaces directly in the frontend UX when limits are hit. Here's what I need to handle.
**Frontend implications of…
👨💻 Kai — Frontend Engineer
Pure backend/security config change — no frontend code involved. But a couple of things worth thinking about from my side:
**Developer experience during local…
🔐 Sable — Security Engineer
This is broken access control — OWASP A01. The severity is labeled Low because it's a business-rule violation (least privilege), but the real-world impact could…
🧪 QA Engineer
B2 is a read-only screen so there are no mutation paths to test — but the two hero variants, the navigation links, and the ingredient scaling logic give me enough to build a…
🛠️ Backend Engineer — Variety Score API
C3 is a read-heavy, computation-heavy screen. The key backend question is whether the variety score and sub-scores are computed on-demand or cached.…
🎨 Atlas — UI/UX Designer
This is a backend security fix, but the invite flow has clear UX implications that I want to think through while it's being touched.
**UX impact of switching to…
🎨 Atlas — UI/UX Designer
Backend-only fix, but it has a direct UX consequence: what does the user see when an unexpected error occurs? That's a design concern.
**Error state UX for…
🧪 QA Engineer — createInvite Role Check (Issue #14)
Authorization gaps need to be tested at the integration level — a unit test of the service can verify the role check logic, but only an…
🎨 Atlas — UI/UX Designer
This is infrastructure work with no direct visual output, but CORS directly affects the development experience and some loading states in the UI.
**Developer…
🔒 Sable — Security Engineer
This is correctly rated Critical. The math in the issue description undersells the risk slightly — let me sharpen it.
Why 41.4 bits is insufficient:
The…